In Search of ... New York's Biggest Slice

Posted by Adam Kuban, August 17, 2006 at 1:51 PM

Koronet Pizza, blogged to Slice from the Flickr photostream of Slice

Just got an AIM from a reader:

SliceReader: "Where's the biggest pizza in NYC?"
NYCSlice: "Koronet."
SliceReader: "Bigger!"
NYCSlice: "???!?"

Anybody out there know of any pizza or slice BIGGER than Koronet?

16 Comments

Tags: big slices, Koronet

16 Comments:

Benny Tudino's, in Hoboken, was famous for their huge slices.

Slice Mr. Cutlets at 12:23AM on 08/18/06

Those one's in hoboken are the size of my torso. I can't remember the name of the place. AH yes, Benny Tudino's. That's it.

Slice Weekly Journalist at 2:51PM on 08/18/06

and I know it's hoboken, but, hell, it's easier to access from midtown Manhattan than DiFara!

Slice Weekly Journalist at 2:54PM on 08/18/06

Last I checked, Hoboken was not in NYC people. Get a grip, it's a nice town but no NYC.

Slice skunky at 3:37PM on 08/18/06

oh, and Koronet rocks the house. How much bigger a slice do you need? I once won a girl's heart by taking her to lunch at Koronet.... ah those halcyon days....

Slice skunky at 3:52PM on 08/18/06

it's accessible by subway.

Slice Weekly Journalist at 4:12PM on 08/18/06

Koronet has the distinction of being delicious and cheap as well as absolutely enormous. There might be bigger slices somewhere in NYC, but I doubt they are worthwhile.

Slice Leland at 10:04PM on 08/18/06

where is koronet? i think this should be a controlled study... ie. where's the biggest $2 regular slice. $2 at Koronet? looks great if so...

Slice thievery at 11:32PM on 08/18/06

There used to be a place in the LIRR part of Penn Station -- by the haagen daz and Fridays -- wedged behind other "chains" -- the slices were LARGE.

Slice HMMMM? MMMMMM! at 12:51AM on 08/19/06

Ljubo's pizza in Westchester Square, Bronx. $2 slice, bigger and better than Koronet's.

Slice Reasons at 1:56AM on 08/19/06

Koronet's were $2.50/slice back when I was a freshman... I've graduated since (haven't been back since frosh yr b/c it's gross) but I think it is in the $2.75-3.00 range. It's on B'way btwn 110 & 111... but Sal & Carmine's on B'way ~102 is much better and cleaner (albeit slightly smaller).

Slice T at 5:42AM on 08/21/06

And NYC is no Hoboken. But if you pay $1.50 on the PATH (not subway), you can enjoy a mighty nice slice there.

Slice CL at 6:26AM on 08/21/06

The Path is a spiritual part of the subway. It goes underground, it's cheap, it connects with the 1/9 at 33rd st. What else could you want.

Slice Weekly Journalist at 5:45PM on 08/21/06

The Caruso's Pizza slices in Penn Station are huge. Penn Station isn't in Hoboken, right?

Slice Alex Zalben at 11:12PM on 08/22/06

No, but there's one in Newark.

Slice Weekly Journalist at 3:57PM on 08/23/06

Moon Pie Pizza on Ave C and 3rd street has huge slices I think they may slice their pies in 6 slices instead of 8

Slice smartone at 9:06PM on 08/23/06

Add a comment:

Previewing your comment:

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it pleasant. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Pizza by Location

Browse the Archives

Slice - slice.seriouseats.com