Reaching in to the Slice mailbag, we've got ...
I know this site is NY-centric, which is fine. I am a Queens boy 50+ years ago. So be it. There is a great PIZZA place in downtown Sturbridge, Massachusetts—Enrico's Pizza.
They have a brick oven and make great heat and wonderful pies but don't do much promotion, as so much of their business is local. They are very "matter-of-fact" and don't make much of their super hot grill, but they have a loyal following. I highly recommend them for inclusion on the Slice site.
Your thoughts welcome.