Daily Slice: Plum Pizzeria and Bar, East Village

Daily Slice gives a quick snapshot each weekday of a different slice or pie that the folks at Serious Eats have enjoyed lately.


[Photographs: Maggie Hoffman]

I'm not sure how to categorize the pizza I had recently at Plum Pizzeria, which opened in the old Cafe Brama space a few months ago. The pie was definitely not Neapolitan, and also not quite New York–style. The crust was rich, slightly dense and crisp, with a hint of buttery flavor. It was a bit thicker than you might expect when ordering what the menu calls "thin crust" pizza. It's a crust sturdy enough to hold generously portioned toppings without any tip sag.


We ordered a small pizza with fresh mozzarella and sausage, which was broken in tiny bits and scattered across the pie ($17.50). The sausage was well-seasoned and moist, with tons of visible fennel seeds. The highlight of the pie was the uncooked sauce, though, which was remarkably fresh and light; it had me wishing we'd ordered our pizza half plain.

Though this pizza as a whole is a bit heftier than I usually prefer, there was something deeply satisfying about it. In a sea of fancy slices and classic slices, Plum's pie feels homemade in an appealing way.

Plum Pizzeria and Bar

157 Second Avenue, New York NY 10003 (map)

More East Village Pizza

Motorino's Amazing Cherrystone Clam Pizza »
Stromboli Pizza »
Luzzo's Great Quadrata Pizza »
Totale's Discount Neapolitan Pizza »
South Brooklyn Pizza »
Solo »
Numero 28 »

Printed from

© Serious Eats