Our favorite pie of the bunch with thick cups of pepperoni, great fennel-riddled housemade sausage, and red onions on a cheese and tomato base. It'll fill you up, and how. One pie is easily enough for two to share.
Assaggini e Sfizi (Small Bites)
Meals start with little cups of intensely flavored bites all in the $4 to $5 range. Our favorites were the Peperoni Friti ($4)—fried shishito peppers with bread crumbs and lemon juice—and the Cetriolo ($4)—bright pickled cucumbers.
Arancini stuffed with mozzarella and pork ragu were deliciously hot and crisp.
The meatballs don't compare to those around the corner at Motorino, and the sauce has the same characteristic dry herb flavor as the pizza sauce.
The only dish that we'd actively steer you away from, the braised calamari was rubbery and extremely fishy smelling—enough that three members of the party came to the independent decision that it had gone off.
Pollo All'Aceto ($10)
White's ode to the buffalo wing is a whole breaded and fried chicken thigh served with a vinegary chili sauce made with Calabrian chilis. Unfortunately, if you're going to riff on something, it has to be better than the original. We found ourselves wishing we could just have some real buffalo wings instead of the over-breaded, under-vinegared chicken thigh.
Mare Salad ($12)
A bright and lemony seafood salad with celery and wild arugula. Some folks have complained of its texture. We found it to be quite lovely with tender squid, octopus, clams, and mussels.
Nicoletta Salad ($9)
Goat cheese-smeared toast may be a cliché, but it's a delicious one, especially when paired with a perfectly dressed salad of crunchy bitter greens, beans, and shaved radishes.
Check out those crisp-edged little cups. Delicious!
Starch-on-starch is not my bag, but if you're a potato lover, this will do fine. It's overtly garlicky and very heavy with plenty of caramelized onions and bacon that early on was limp, but not comes crisped perfectly.
Dense, thick, and crunchy is the way they do it here.
White's version of the classic broccoli rabe and sausage pizza comes with plenty of porky homemade sausage, Calabrian chilis, and a handful of marinated tomatoes with garlic.
The Rim Shot
"We brush our crust with olive oil right when it comes out of the oven so you get that aroma up front in your face when it gets to the table," says Chef White.
Mozzarella, tomatoes, ricotta, and fried eggplant.
The best thing on the menu is the spectacular vanilla soft serve with an insanely lengthy and delicious toppings bar. Pistachio cumble or rosemary kettle corn is the way to go.