You all have TXCraig1 to thank for this trip down memory lane—he emailed Slice this old Garbage Pail Kids image. I was sure I remembered trading the card back in the day for the less subtle Acne Amy. But after doing some digging around, I discovered the card wasn't printed until 2004 as Cheesy Charlie or Pizza Face Chase when the new Garbage Pail Kids series was released!* Prior to that, it only made it into the poster version you see here.
*Oh you wanna know more? I happen to have some extra trivia knowledge on the subject.This card got passed over twice! It was initially slated for release in the original series 2 and then again in the original series16, as Guy Pie and Pepperoni Toni. Thanks, gpk.wiki. Now that is more than you ever needed to know on the subject.