'New York Pizza Suprema' on Serious Eats

The Best Pizza in Penn Station (And Down the Street)

Hola, cheeseheads. Please welcome Aaron Mattis to Slice. Aaron just joined us last week as Slice's summer intern (our first dedicated Slice intern, yay!). As a fun first assignment, we sent Aaron up to Penn Station (along with Serious Eats intern Lingbo Li on photo duty) to suss out the best pizza in the busy transit hub. Without further ado, Aaron's report. —The Mgmt. The upside-down slice from NY Pizza Suprema is worth the walk from Penn Station. [Photographs: Lingbo Li] Although Slice'rs in transit can no longer enjoy the beautiful architecture of the original Penn Station, they can take... More

Dear Slice: Good Delivery Pizza for Office at 26th and 11th Avenue?

Clicking in to the Slice inbox today, we've got ... I want to get pizza for lunch for Jaime B.'s going-away party. Is Waldy's any good? How many people can I feed w/one of his large pies? (Any guesses? I know I can call and ask.) What about Pizza Suprema--how many can I feed with one of their larges? I still have horrible memories of my attempt to treat Adam w/pizza from Lazzara's on his bday at Blueprint, and not having nearly enough food. Is there anyone else you'd suggest? (Am I too far away from Lazzara's to ask them... More

Lunch: New York Pizza Suprema

New York Pizza Suprema calls this an "upside down pizza," but it's essentially a Sicilian slice that goes crust, cheese, sauce instead of crust, sauce, cheese. We had it for lunch today at Slice–Serious Eats HQ.... More

New York Pizza Suprema

If you find yourself headed to Madison Square Garden for a Knicks or Rangers game or a concert and you have 15 minutes or less to get something to eat, Pizza Suprema is the answer to your prayers. A mere two blocks from a Garden entrance, it looks like a generic pizzeria. Don't be fooled. The regular slices have a crisp crust, a fine if overly sweet sauce and a little too much cheese. Have one regular slice and one slice of the marinara pie—a Sicilian slice coated with marinara sauce containing flecks of fresh onion, then sprinkled with... More

More Posts