Yesterday I blabbled about Pizza Moto at the Brooklyn Bridge Flea. Today, I share with you another weekend pizza trip I made—to V&T Pizzeria in Morningside Heights.
I know that this is going to punch some nostalgia buttons among you Columbia alumni in the audience—but it might also make you want to punch me.
See, I didn't think V&T was all that.
I first visited V&T a few times with onetime Slice contributor E-Rock, who was attending Columbia's J-school at the time. After hearing that it was the best in the neighborhood, I was disappointed. Especially when we got a mushroom pizza with canned mushrooms.
1024 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY 10025 (111th Street/Cathedral Parkway; map); 212-663-1708
Now I know that some folks prefer them to fresh 'shrooms on a pizza, and I just may have to investigate this a little bit at some point, but at the time I was not a fan. Still, it wasn't just the mushrooms that did the pizza in. I found it way too cheesy, way too saucy, and way too altogether soupy. And I don't think removing the mushrooms would have changed any of that. In fact, when we had a plain pie there, it made little difference.
But seeing as how Girl Slice keeps threatening to write a column for Slice/Serious Eats called "Unpopular Opinions," and seeing as how one of the topics she keeps threatening to cover is "Hey All You Haters, V&T Is Actually Good," I went again with her after she had finished with an errand at Columbia on Friday night.
I'm going to instantly lose cred here when I say we ordered a half (fresh) mushroom–half pineapple pie. Yes, pineapple. Girl Slice is a fan of pineapple, and I have to admit I like it on occasion. (It's actually not bad with pepperoni; and I'm wondering how it would do with some nice hot soppressata.)
The fresh mushrooms were an improvement over the canned, and the pie was less soggy than I remembered, but it also seemed to have lost something. Even when it was soggy when I last tried it, it did seem to have its own character. This time, the crust was soft and doughy—almost like a Domino's "Hand Tossed" pizza, and the sauce had that generic pizza-chain flavor to it. The cheese was good—creamy, melty, and stringy—and there were some nice crusty bits of dough and baked-on cheese at the end crusts, but it was imminently forgettable.
In the end I think it's telling that Girl Slice remembered V&T more as a place she used to go to catch up with classmates—recalling stories of dinners there with this friend or that—than for the food itself.
All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy.