The big news in LaGuardia-based pizza, of course, is that Dom DeMarco Jr. has opened a Di Fara–inspired pizzeria, Tagliare, in the Delta Air Lines terminal.
I am not in the Delta terminal, where the pizza options are so promising. Instead, I took one for the team and sampled Joey's Pizza in the U.S. Airways Terminal.
A plain slice and a pepperoni-mushroom slice will represent the pizzeria for purposes of this rundown. Both had been sitting long enough that the quality had been significantly compromised.
The too-soft, spongy crust did not crisp up even after a lengthy reheat in the oven. Though, to be fair, the pizza here pretty much mirrors a mediocre New York slice you'd get at a typical mediocre slice shop. That is to say, it's not any worse for being airport pizza and is, unfortunately, representative of too large a number of NYC pizzerias where you might go for a mindless lunchtime fill-up.
The $3.39 price for a regular slice and the $4.99 whopper for the pepperoni-mushroom slice, however, is where you're reminded all too quickly that you are indeed in an airport.
Well, that and the constant flight-delay announcements.
Other options in the food court are Sky Asian Bistro, McDonald's, Mex in the City (agh, pun, groan), Dunkin' Donuts, a generic-looking table-service restaurant, and something called Cibo Express, a Pret or Au Bon Pain knock-off that serves overpriced sandwiches, granola, fruit salads, etc. Given all that, Joey's might actually be your best, cheapest option.
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.