Get the Recipe
If the store-bought sausage you've been using on your pizza is a little limp in the flavor department but you've been hesitant to make your own, this concoction couldn't be easier to pull together. You don't need a meat grinder, casings, or sausage stuffer. You probably have most of the ingredients on hand, too, if your spice drawer is stocked. Most of the work involves a trip to the butcher.
This recipe comes from Mark Bello of Pizza a Casa. Bello makes a batch of this intensely flavorful fennel-studded pork sausage as a topping option for each session of the pizzamaking class he teaches at the "Pizza Self-Sufficiency Center."
I've made it for my own "pizza nights" a couple times now, and I have a hard time not using it on every pizza in the evening lineup.
On pizza, it's reminiscent of the sausage you'll find at places with a long history of tastiness — and that's not a coincidence. Bello says:
My sausage recipe is modeled after my favorite New Jersey/NYC fennel-seed-studded sausage found on the tasty twice-baked slices of yore at the mom-and-pop pizza shops at the mall, on the boardwalk, or at the NYC corner joint. At each place it was cut from a par-cooked link — never the crumbled stuff that always got all dried out and yucky. I don't encase my sausage, but sufficiently sized chunks and proper par-cooking is key for proper juiciness.
Ready to make this yet? Good.
Here's What You'll Need
Ground pork: Bello says, "I use everything from killer heritage breed varieties to kick-ass, fresh-ground all-day-long stuff I get near my apartment in Chinatown. If you don't have the myriad of NYC foodstuffs at your fingertips, ask your butcher for a blend of Boston butt and fat back, coarse ground and at 75/25 lean to fat. That's usually an 8- to 10-pound commitment, but make a big batch o' sausage and freeze it in pizza-party-ready deli pint containers. It freezes well. Just thaw in the fridge overnight."
If you're not quite ready for that level of commitment, just get a pound of coarsely ground pork, as close to the 3:1 meat-fat ratio as you can get. That's what I get from my local butcher, and it works well. Of course, if you have a meat grinder and are ambitious, there's nothing stopping you from grinding your own.
Seasonings: You probably have most of these in your pantry. Salt, garlic powder, red pepper flakes, and fennel seeds.
I didn't have fennel seeds myself and had to hunt around my neighborhood for them. Pizza a Casa actually sells some "I that seem ideal for sausage-making. Says Bello, "They're smaller than typical fennel seeds and they really sing in the sausage—no pre-toasting necessary, either." A $5 bag should be enough for 5 pounds of sausage, he says.
And while that might sound like a pitch, I'm eager to try the smaller seeds once I run out of my own at home. I lose a small amount of seeds when I break up the sausage for topping — I'm guessing the smaller variety will better incorporate into the mixture.
Maybe this will please the folks looking for pizza sausage recipes in this Talk topic.
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.