Connecticut is the buckle of the Northeastern pizza belt, which stretches from Pennsylvania to Massachusetts. More specifically, the New Haven style of pizza not only is one of the first uniquely American pizza styles, but it has been preserved by a cluster of family-run establishments which still in many cases use the original equipment, now almost a century old.
Naturally New Haven might be considered Connecticut's pizza capital, but the state has dozens of great pizzerias. Few other places in the country have as much great pizza per capita (PPC). These are the best eight pizzas in Connecticut that we have had to date.
Click through the slideshow above for photos of each one (or just click a link below to jump straight to an individual slide).
- Plain Pie at Sally's Apizza
- Colony Grill's Hot Oil Pie
- Modern Apizza's Mozzarella and Sausage Pie
- Clam Pie at Zuppardi's
- Roseland Apizza's Plain Pie
- The Italian Job at Mulberry Street Pizza
- Bar's Sausage and Cherry Pepper Pizza
- White Clam with Bacon at Frank Pepe's
Whittling down all the top pizzas in Connecticut that we've tasted to just eight was no easy task. Even some of the pizzerias that did make the final cut have multiple pies that could easily hold a spot on a pizza lover's 'best of' list. Out in Meriden, a 123-year-old coal oven has been firing apizza pies since 1938 at Little Rendezvous. The roadside pizza shack is a slice of Americana and a dying breed that merits a pit stop if your in the area. The citizens of Danbury have been well-served by the addition of the wood-fired pies at Stanziato's, proving that New Haven isn't the only style with strong representation in the state. Providing more evidence for that case are the Neapolitan pies at Tarry Lodge in Westport from the Batali/Bastianich group. And along the shoreline in Old Saybrook, Alforno offers worthy New Haven style pies outside of the pizza capital, just minutes off of I-95.
Now it's your turn. What are some of your favorite pies in the Nutmeg State?
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.